As surprising as some of Democrats’ Senate victories this month seemed to be, the closer one looks the more some of these results make sense, particularly given the rapid deterioration of President Trump’s standing, and that of his fellow Republicans, during the last 10 weeks before the election.
Perhaps I am being stubborn in resisting the temptation to call the election a “blue wave,” simply because I have a hard time saying that a party with underwater favorability ratings is the beneficiary of a wave. To me, the term “wave” should correspond with a national affirmation of support for one party. That would not seem to be the case this year.
Recently I quoted Mitch Bainwol, the executive director of the National Republican Senatorial Committee in 2002, who argues that over the last quarter century, voters have been “firing, not hiring.” Now I have to credit Bainwol with another good one: “Not losing isn’t winning.” In an amped-up rendition of what usually happens in midterm elections, the president’s party faced an 80 mph headwind, buttressed by a bigger advantage than normal for the out party among independents.
A look at the recent presidential voting habits of all 50 states, combined with 2026 Senate election results, brings to mind another oceanographic saying: A rising tide lifts all boats. From ocean liners and aircraft carriers at one end of the spectrum to rowboats and canoes on the other, nearly every Democratic boat rose.
The attached table arranges the states from the least Democratic to the most, based on their average presidential votes in the three elections of the Trump era. Bottom line: With one exception, the Democratic tide rose as far as Mississippi, the 15th-most-Republican state. While the Magnolia State is certainly a very red Southern state, it doesn’t make the top 10, thanks in part to a very large Black population. Black voters have been outraged over GOP efforts to eliminate predominantly African American districts in the Deep South, and they voted in huge numbers across the region.
That one exception came in Florida, the 24th-most-Republican state, where appointed Sen. Ashley Moody prevailed in the Senate race over state Rep. Angie Nixon.
The table suggests a pretty uniform swing toward Democrats, which was evident almost regardless of candidate and campaign quality. The three most important factors in real estate, it has long been said, are “location, location, location.” In politics, it is timing, timing, and timing. Democrats had some amazingly talented candidates and well-organized and uniquely positioned candidates. Others didn’t have much of a campaign at all. But they benefited from being in the right place at the right time. In a few cases, Democrats won races that would have had a different outcome under almost any other set of circumstances.
Coming off of the 2024 election, Republicans over-read the results. They gloated over drops in Democratic support among some traditionally Democratic groups, such as Latinos, African Americans, and younger voters. They thought those shifts would be permanent. But the fact that younger, non-college males turned against the party in the White House at a time of newly rampant inflation and interest rates shouldn’t have been a surprise. One election or exit-poll result does not establish a new trend.
Democrats now savoring gains in the Deep South and in the Farm Belt should take heed of that lesson. Many of this month’s results may well have been the product of specific circumstances of this cycle, coupled with unusually weak GOP nominees and campaigns in certain states and districts, more than a sign that the laws of political gravity have suddenly been reversed.
It is worth remembering that the most recent election is not the last election that will ever be held. The results are not a permanent state. Two years later, the high tides often recede.
